You've walked past that drip for three weeks. Tap-tap-tap at the base of the showerhead, every shower. It feels like touching it will turn it into something worse. It won't. Most of the time it's ten minutes and a roll of tape.
Last updated: October 2026 · By Gen X Still Standing
Two completely different problems get lumped together as "the shower's leaking." One is water dripping at the threaded connection, where the showerhead screws onto the arm. That's a tape-and-tighten job. Ten minutes, done. The other is the shower dripping when the valve is fully off, with water coming from inside the wall. That one you don't touch.
Tape, a wrench and a new showerhead if you need one run $5 to $40. A lot of service calls cost $100 to $150 just for the guy to show up.
The full step-by-step is in the Fire the Guy playbook. Grab the free list below to get started.
There's basically no risk here beyond stripping a fitting if you overtighten it. Snug is the goal.
Call a plumber if the leak is behind the wall, there's water damage at the trim, or you can't identify the cartridge family. And remember: tape won't fix a valve that drips when it's off.
I learned the trades hands-on and ran my own construction company in Colorado. I've watched other contractors do to homeowners exactly what this page teaches you to stop. Not knowing is where the upsell lives. Now you know.
Get the free cheat sheet: 5 repairs people overpay for, what's usually wrong, and what the part costs at the hardware store.
Free. You'll also get the weekly newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy.
How much does it cost to fix?
PTFE thread tape, an adjustable wrench and a new showerhead if needed run $5 to $40.
Will tape fix a shower that drips when it's off?
No. A valve that drips when it's off is a cartridge or seat problem, not a threading problem.
When should I call a plumber?
If the leak is behind the wall, there's water damage at the trim, or you can't identify the cartridge family.
Educational only. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and your local codes. When in doubt, call a licensed plumber. Built by a Gen Xer with AI, for Gen Xers.